Your first draft is supposed to be a mess


MARYLEE MACDONALD

Hello Reader,

I want to let you in on a secret that took me years to accept: your first draft is not supposed to be good.

I'm serious. The goal of a first draft is not to produce publishable prose. The goal is to get the story out of your head and onto the page. That's it. Everything else comes later.

I used to write a sentence, hate it, delete it, and rewrite it. I did this for hours. I produced almost nothing. A wise writing teacher finally told me: "Marylee, you can't edit a blank page." She was right.

The Two-Pass Rule

Here's what I do now. I write the whole first draft without looking back. Then I put it in a drawer for at least a month. Then I read it through once, just to see what's there. I circle sections that make me feel anxious, empathetic, or afraid. I pencil in question marks when I feel confused. On the second pass, I start fixing things.

If you can give yourself permission to write badly, you'll write more. And the more you write, the better your odds of landing on something worth keeping.

The trick is to separate the creator from the editor. They can't both show up at the same time. Let the creator have the first hour. The editor gets her turn later.

A Challenge for You

This week, try writing 500 words without stopping to edit a single one. Don't fix typos. Don't reread the previous paragraph. Just go.

Hit reply and tell me how it goes. I'd love to hear what you discover.

Sincerely,

Marylee MacDonald

P.S. If you're working on a novel right now, I'd love to know what's giving you the most trouble. Send me a note. I read every reply.

800 Blossom Hill Rd., Los Gatos, CA 95032-3567
Unsubscribe · Preferences


✦ THIS WEEK'S FEATURED BOOK ✦

Friends for a Season

by Brad Graber

Helena was once a celebrated author, speaker, and activist. Then a fall changed everything. Convinced her independence is gone and that the world has forgotten her, she reluctantly moves into a retirement community. The last thing she expects is a new friendship with Zak, a college freshman who is just as lost and alone as she is.

This intergenerational story is a reminder that the connections that change us most arrive when we least expect them, and that it's never too late to begin again.

Available now on Amazon: Friends for a Season →

Brad Graber is an award-winning author of multiple novels exploring friendship, connection, and the family we choose. Learn more at www.bradgraber.com.


Hi! I'm Marylee MacDonald

I'm an author and author coach, and I love helping new writers achieve their dreams. Check out the resources I offer and sign up for my newsletter!

Read more from Hi! I'm Marylee MacDonald

MARYLEE MACDONALD Hello Reader, I want to talk about book covers today, because I see authors make the same mistake over and over. They spend a year writing a beautiful book, then put a homemade cover on it that signals to every potential reader: "This is an amateur." Readers really do judge books by their covers. That's not cynical. It's how their brains work. A cover tells a reader in less than three seconds whether your book belongs in their hands. What a Professional Cover Does A great...

MARYLEE MACDONALD Hello Reader, Almost every week someone emails me a version of this question: "Do I really need an email list?" The answer is yes. Full stop. No asterisk. Here's why. Social media platforms come and go. Algorithms change overnight. A platform that sends your posts to thousands of followers this year might bury them next year. Your email list is the one thing no platform can take away. The Number That Changed My Mind A recent survey of indie authors found that writers earning...

a list of ways to see if a writer's book has had its copyright infringed upon

Hello Reader, The Anthropic Settlement March 30, 2026 is the deadline to submit a claim in the $1.5 billion Anthropic Book Copyright Settlement. Was your book illegally uploaded by Anthropic? Check the ISBN, publisher, or author name to find out. Filing a claim is quick and easy. https://www.anthropiccopyrightsettlement.com/ You can get additional information about the Settlement or download a mail-in Claim Form at www.AnthropicCopyrightSettlement.com. RIP NanoWriMo NaNoWriMo--National Novel...